What is Normal Return?

I been wanting to write this post for sometime and finally got to do it today. We have seen turbulent economic conditions for the last few years that have brought returns which doesn’t really match any previous years. It brings to us a big question, What is the Normal Return?. Here is a snapshot of an article published TRoweprice analyst last year.

What is the Normal Return?

There may not be a right answer. When looking at short-term holding periods, such as one year, it has been normal for the market to have ‘abnormal’ returns. With extreme total returns of -37% in 2008 and about 26.5% in 2009—as measured by the S&P 500 Index—even the most steadfast investors may have struggled with their emotions. The S&P 500 Index is comprised of 500 stocks chosen for market size, liquidity and industry grouping, among other factors. The S&P 500 is designed to be a leading indicator of U.S. equities and is meant to reflect the risk/return characteristics of the large cap universe.

However, 2010’s return of 15.06% was closer to the index’s historical annualized return since 1926 of 9.87%. Is that a more typical year? Indeed, how should investors evaluate their returns?

While the future isn’t predictable, past returns can offer some insights. Consider the chart on this page, which shows the distribution of the S&P 500 Index’s annual total returns since 1926.


A quick glance shows how infrequently the market has declined more than 10% in a year. More evident, though, is that the market returned more than 10% in 48 out of the last 85 years, or more than 56% of the years.

While there is a wide variation of returns, the years in which returns were positive by 10% or more have been much more common than any other outcome.

If the market volatility of the last few years has made investors question their investment strategies, they, likely, are not alone.

How to Avoid making changes during this unstable periods?
Investors may want to take into account this long-term pattern of returns when they are questioning their asset allocation decisions after a year of underperformance. When returns are low or negative, it’s natural to feel that you have to act, but action isn’t always in favor of the investor. Changing an asset allocation decision based solely on the returns of 2008 is just as irrelevant as changing your asset allocation based solely on the returns of 2009. You have to step back and put your portfolio in the context of long-term returns.

Emotional Reactions to Volatility Is Our Worst Enemy
Emotional reactions to market volatility can be investors’ worst enemy. Having a well thought out investment strategy is the first step to conquering the ups and downs of the market.

In conclusion, don’t focus more on the last year’s return, investors in stocks and stock funds may do better making their investment decisions based on their risk tolerance and the time horizon of their financial goals. You can check out my last blog posted about How Risk Tolerance and Time Horizon plays key role in your investment goals.

Risk Tolerance & Time Horizon are the keys

As a Self directed Investor many of you are very much aware of the fact that Risk plays a key role in your investment return. If you are novice investor, you know in general terms more return needs more risk. It always the fight between Risk versus Return. Investors has to get their act together to find a balance between the level of risk they are willing to take in order to get a reasonable return for their investment.


Image credit: investopedia.com

The investing strategy decisions shouldn’t be only based on Risk tolerance but also accompanied by another factor, Time. Time Horizon is second major factor to drive your financial planning decisions. Even though there are other factors involved in financial planning, these two factors Risk Tolerance and Investment Horizon are key to achieve your financial goals.

Risk Tolerance
Risk tolerance is all about how much risk one is willing to take to achieve expected return. As many theories explain, high return needs high risk which is associated with high level of uncertainty. But if you are satisfied with low return, low risk with low uncertainty would be the way to go. It is the argument about whether to put the money in savings, CD’s, Bonds Versus Equities. The simple chart below shows clearly that as the risk increase return increase and vice versa.



The starting point of the line is where one can get risk risk-free rate of return which normally associated with US Securities like Treasuries and Bonds. There is no risk associated with these type of investing to get low rate of return as US securities never defaulted. As you diversify your investment by investing in equities like stocks and Mutual funds, your risk increase as well expected return increase. Risk tolerance level changes depending on one’s age and financial goals. If you are 30 and planning to invest for retirement, your risk tolerance is high compared to one approaching retirement. That brings up to second key factor, Time Horizon.

Time Horizon
In above example, 30 year old has more time to build the wealth needed to reach the goal by taking more risk compared to one approaching the retirement. Taking the Risk tolerance level and combining with time horizon would lead to various asset allocation strategies which can be implemented depending on your financial goals. See the below chart.



Risk Averse Investor
It is good to take high risk to get expected returns but if you have two investments with similar returns but varied risk. It is wise to go with low risk investment. These type of investors are called Risk Averse Investors. As per Modern Portfolio theory, risk-averse investors try to construct portfolios to maximize their expected return based on a given level of market risk. Don’t try to over smart the market, try to be Risk Averse Investor to achieve your financial goals smartly.

Investment Tools
You don’t have to be expert investor or financial geek, there are lots of tools available these days for ordinary consumers. In recent past few years, many veteran mutual fund companies like TRowePrice, Vanguard and small fund companies which serves more online clients like Betterment.com, Funds.com have built their own tools based on these two main key factors. These tools simply drive the customers to make a decision on which funds to select by setting their risk tolerance level and time horizon. It is the simplest way to start investing for your future financial goals.

In conclusion, always try to remember that right amount risk level and proper time period is driven by your financial goals and helps to implement efficient investment strategies to reach your financial well being.

2012 ShareBuilder Discount & Bonus offer for Costco Members

In the past, Costco partnered with INGDirect Sharebuilder to offer sign on bonus for their members. It was usually $50 for GoldStar Members and $90 for Executive members. I have signed to make use the offer 3 years ago and I been using sharebuilder on and off for my dollar cost average investment strategy.

Last year offer ended on Jan 31st, so they came up with the new offer which is not the same but little bit better to motivate investing more and take advantage of the discount. For All Costco Members, whether New or Existing Accounts at ShareBuilder.com,
Savings Highlights*

  • $2 automatic investments
  • $6.95 to trade now

With that, only for Executive Members, the sign up bonus would be $50.

Compare the Savings

Basic Program ShareBuilder
Price
Costco
Member Price
 Savings
 Trade Now   $9.95   $6.95   30%
 Automatic
Investments**
  $4   $2   50%
 Options
Trading
$9.95/online trade
+$1.25/contract
$6.95/online trade
+$1.25/contract
  30%

If you are setup automatic savings investment, you will only spend $2 compared to $4. For Regular trade, you will pay $6.95 which equal to Scottrade commission price and better than other discount brokers. You will either way. I would say it is good offer to start your dollar cost averaging and start investing passively.

For more info, you can visit sharebuilder.com/feb2012